Why Old Franchise Agreements Can Create New Problems for Franchisors

Old franchise agreements can expose franchisors to new compliance, enforcement and operational risks. Renewals and extensions are often the ideal time to update franchise documents to reflect the current Franchising Code and modern best practice.

Many franchisors assume that if an older franchise agreement has worked well enough in the past, it is safest to keep using it. That can be a costly assumption.

A franchise agreement is not a document that stays current simply because it remains signed and in place. Over time, the legal framework changes, the franchise system evolves, operating practices become more sophisticated, and what once seemed adequate can become outdated. The result is that an old agreement may no longer properly support the franchisor’s current business model, compliance obligations or enforcement position.

This issue has become even more important under the current Franchising Code of Conduct. A new Code took effect on 1 April 2025, with some additional obligations applying from 1 November 2025. Importantly, the new rules apply not only to brand new agreements, but also to agreements that are entered into, renewed, extended or transferred from 1 April 2025.

Old agreements often lag behind the current Code

One of the clearest risks with older franchise agreements is compliance drift.

The Franchising Code does not stand still, and neither do the expectations around franchise documentation. The current Code introduced from 1 April 2025, together with the further changes that became mandatory from 1 November 2025, includes important requirements touching areas such as significant capital expenditure disclosure, specific purpose funds, reasonable opportunity to make a return on investment, compensation for early termination, and restraint of trade.

An agreement drafted several years ago may not have been built with these settings in mind. In some cases, the problem is obvious. In others, the agreement may look acceptable on its face, but it sits awkwardly beside the franchisor’s current disclosure documents, operating practices or risk profile.

The danger is not always that the old agreement is plainly unlawful. Often, the problem is that it no longer aligns cleanly with the current regulatory environment, creating uncertainty at the very point where clarity matters most.

Renewals and extensions are often missed opportunities

This is one of the most important points for franchisors to understand.

A renewal or extension should not be treated as a purely administrative exercise. It is often the best opportunity a franchisor has to move a franchisee from legacy documents onto updated documents that reflect the current Code, the current system and current best practice.

If an existing franchise agreement is transferred, renewed or extended on or after 1 April 2025, the new Code becomes relevant. In practical terms, that means a franchisor who simply rolls forward an old agreement may miss the chance to modernise key provisions, address known weaknesses, and align the legal documents with the franchisor’s current operating model. What looks like the easy option can actually preserve old risk.

Legacy documents often do not reflect how the system now operates

Even where there is no immediate compliance issue, old agreements often create operational problems because the franchise system has moved on.

Many franchise networks now rely on centralised lead handling, digital platforms, CRM systems, mandatory software, more sophisticated reporting requirements, enhanced training obligations, online sales channels, broader supplier controls and tighter brand governance. Yet older agreements may have been written for a much simpler operating environment.

That creates a mismatch between the legal document and the real-world system.

A franchisor may assume it has the right to require compliance with certain modern processes because those processes are now standard across the network. But if the agreement does not clearly support those requirements, enforcement can become more difficult. Inconsistent drafting can also create space for dispute, especially where a franchisee resists change or argues that the current requirement was never properly incorporated into the bargain.

An agreement that no longer matches the way the system actually works is not just dated. It is less useful.

Old drafting usually becomes a problem when enforcement is needed

A weak agreement often goes unnoticed while the relationship is cooperative.

The problem usually appears later, when the franchisor needs to rely on the document. That may be because of underperformance, operational non-compliance, a dispute about territory, resistance to system changes, a proposed transfer, or an end-of-term issue.

Older agreements frequently contain drafting that is too vague, too light or too inconsistent for modern enforcement purposes. The document may not deal clearly enough with matters such as operational manuals, digital systems, audit rights, reporting obligations, supplier arrangements, intellectual property controls, territory flexibility, step-in rights, or post-term restraints.

At that point, the age of the document stops being a background issue and becomes a front-end commercial problem. The franchisor may find that the agreement it assumed would protect the system does not do so as clearly or effectively as it should.

That is why old agreements can be so misleading. They often appear fine until the moment they are tested.

Different generations of agreements can create inconsistency across the network

Another common problem is document inconsistency.

Where a franchisor has been operating for some time, it is not unusual for different franchisees to be on different generations of agreements. Some may be on significantly older forms, while others are on newer documents with updated provisions. That can lead to uneven rights and obligations across the network.

Inconsistency may arise in relation to restraint wording, renewal rights, technology obligations, supplier controls, online sales, fees, territory settings, reporting requirements or end-of-term arrangements. This does not just create administrative inefficiency. It can also undermine the franchisor’s ability to manage the network consistently and confidently.

Franchisees talk to each other. Differences between document sets do not stay hidden for long. Once they become known, they can create tension, negotiation pressure and unnecessary disputes about fairness or precedent.

For that reason, reviewing old agreements is not merely a legal housekeeping exercise. It is also a system governance issue.

Older agreements may also hold back future growth

A modern franchise agreement should not only protect the franchisor. It should also support the way the franchise system is intended to grow.

Legacy documents may not adequately deal with newer revenue channels, revised service models, system-wide technology, changing training expectations, customer data issues, or evolving brand standards. They may also lack the flexibility needed to support future expansion, tighter operational consistency, or a more contemporary approach to managing network performance.

That means the real cost of an old agreement is not always visible in the form of immediate legal risk. Sometimes the cost is slower decision-making, weaker controls, more exceptions, and a system that is harder to modernise than it should be.

In that sense, old franchise agreements do not just create legal problems. They can create strategic ones as well.

The real issue is not age alone

Not every old franchise agreement is necessarily defective, and not every long-standing document needs to be discarded immediately.

But age should prompt review, not comfort.

The real question is whether the agreement still reflects the current Code, the current system and the current commercial realities of the network. If it does not, then what appears familiar and convenient may actually be exposing the franchisor to avoidable risk.

A renewal, extension or transfer is often the ideal time to ask that question properly. Treated the right way, it can be an opportunity to strengthen compliance, improve enforceability and bring the legal framework of the system into line with how the business now operates.

Need a second set of eyes on your franchise documents?

If your franchise agreement, disclosure document and related documents have not been reviewed recently, now is a good time to check whether they still reflect the current Code and current best practice.

Aventus Legal offers a fixed-price Franchise Health Check for $3,000 including GST. We review your existing franchise documents, identify compliance issues and outdated provisions, and provide practical written recommendations to help you modernise your documentation and reduce risk.

If you would like a fresh legal review of your franchise agreement and disclosure suite, get in touch to discuss the Franchise Health Check.